Jonestown the Life and Death of Peoples Temple Reviews
Spooky tragedy: over 900 cult members follow their leader'southward gild to accept part in a mass suicide
This is a sad, chilling documentary about the rise and fall of psychopathic cult leader Jim Jones'due south People's Temple. Back home in Indiana, Jones had a morbid fascination with death and charismatic religion as early on as age 5. He displayed an admirable acceptance of people of color, but he also killed small animals to serve every bit subjects for death rituals he conducted, a disturbing trait not exceptionally associated with adult personality leanings toward callous violence.
Untrained in the ministry, he nonetheless started his own church in Indiana - an offshoot of the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) - while still in his early on 20s, afterward, in 1965, moving it west to a rural commune-similar setting in Ukiah, in Northern California, when he was 34, where he also renamed the church building People's Temple Total Gospel Church.
Afterward 9 years, in 1974 he moved the church again, this time to San Francisco, where he ingratiated himself with local politicos like George Moscone and Willie Brown, and, in return for his back up of Moscone for Mayor, Jones was appointed to the urban center'due south housing committee. By 1977 Jones had the crawling to move over again, and this time his church bought a big tract of land in the interior of Guyana, in northwestern South America. In that location a settlement, Jonestown, was rapidly established to permanently business firm over ane,000 church members. In November, 1978, after receiving complaints that all was non well in Jonestown, that people were being forcibly separated from loved ones back home and more than or less held hostage, a California Congressman, Leo Ryan, made a trip to Jonestown to run across for himself what was going on.
Ryan never returned, for he was shot and killed on the aircraft runway at Jonestown by armed stooges of Jones's, on orders to do then considering Jones feared that Ryan would bring trouble if allowed to return to usa. Later on that same day, November 18, 1978, Jones used his extensive PA organisation to order all of his supplicants to take a cyanide drink, to escape the misery that would befall Jonestown once authorities came in large numbers, to go on over to the other side, i.eastward., presumably to Heaven, where they would find peace.
911 church members died that 24-hour interval, many infants and children given toxicant by their parents, who then besides took the toxicant drink to create possibly the largest mass suicide in history. Some who did non have poison were, similar Rep. Ryan, shot to death. This was likewise the apparent cause of death for Jones himself. Another lxxx members were away on some sort of field trip and were spared.
This is the fifth and perchance most unusual of director Stanley Nelson'due south documentaries, which always concern race and the African-American condition (his prior feature films have taken upwardly black press journalists; Marcus Garvey; Oaks Barefaced, a black summertime community on Martha'south Vineyard; and the musical group Sweet Honey in the Stone).
Nelson'south interest in Jonestown is connected with the fact that a bulk of Jones'south supplicants were black. Jones pandered to the suffering of poor blacks and whites alike. He also had sexual activity with many women in the church, and even offered to sodomize anyone - female or male person - who asked for or wanted this kind of connection to him, and apparently many did.
Nelson's approach here is intensely personal. He intercuts archival footage - of Jones'due south life, his activities and various stages in the evolution of his church - with gimmicky interviews of persons who lost loved ones in Guyana. There are no talking heads: no sociologists, no academics who study religious cults, not a single mental health professional to educate us here. Nelson doesn't want us to understand the root causes of this tragedy; he wants u.s. to feel the hurting, the grief that this horrible and senseless loss of life wrought, but to feed the craving for ability that was obviously Jones's master source of sustenance. It is an agonizing story to witness. My grades: vii/ten, B (Seen on 11/25/06)
34 out of 36 plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A compelling story
I have heard about the cult "Peoples Temple" before, but I knew petty nigh it. Through large amount of rare footages and in depth interviews of the Peoples Temple survivors and family members of the members of Peoples Temple, the documentary takes a deep look into this cult and tries to find out why 909 people committed "mass murder/suicide" on Nov xviii, 1978 in Jonestown, Republic of guyana.
This flick is what a neat documentary looks like. It goes across the headline and dig deep into the story. I begin to understand whom Jim Jones was. I begin to understand why so many people crossed the racial and social boundaries to come together and fifty-fifty devoted their lives to this cult leader and their "church." Many of the cult followers were struggling with the social injustice and racial discrimination in the 60s and 70s. Jim Jones offered them equality and sense of belonging that the society didn't offer. And so Peoples Temple becomes their utopia where they could be so happy and united. Only the sad part is that later some of them realize they were betrayed and they had no style out.
This is definitely a great documentary I have seen this yr and I surely hope it volition get an Oscar nomination.
24 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Interesting, well-structured documentary with effective utilize of contributions and video
Ah yep, another opportunity to mention The Wire as all fans tirelessly (and tiresomely) practise; I was reminded of the Jonestown massacre (and that is how I see it) by a Spearhead track on the series soundtrack and coincidentally this film was on a week or so afterwards I heard it. My cognition of the events in Jonestown can be summarised into one brusk sentence so this film interested me past offer more than than a uncomplicated summary. Using footage from inside the People'south Temple movement equally well equally interviews with former members this builds the story chronologically from early stages through to the tragic conclusion to the move.
In that location are many challenges and traps associated with telling this story and mostly this motion picture works because it avoids the bulk of them and deals well with the telling. The first challenge is to get the viewer to a signal where it is at least understandable how Jones could atomic number 82 such a movement to such an extent. Ane of the contributors says that nobody sets out to join a cult that volition injure them but yet the film makes it reasonably clear why and then many people ultimately did and why so many people put up with so much out-and-out weirdness and oppression. In doing this the textile naturally suggests that Jones is a monster or crazy and it would have been like shooting fish in a barrel to ham this attribute upwards with music etc to the detriment of the film. As information technology works out, the film doesn't do this and instead lets events speak for themselves without really pulling cheap tricks to sensationalise or demonise anyone unnecessarily.
As a result it all comes over fifty-fifty handed and fair. The heavy utilize of those directly involved makes information technology a lot more interesting than a heavy narrator-led approach because you hear things starting time hand and have an insiders perception of events. Some viewers volition feel the lack of conspiracy in the picture show but I did not because the film was on the full general sweep of the tragedy rather than suggested stories backside it. OK and then the cloth does a lot of the work by having a lot of inherent involvement inside it but fifty-fifty still this documentary is effectively structured with a good personal presentation that gets within the world of the People'due south Temple and Jonestown.
8 out of 9 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
powerful
I saw this film Tuesday afternoon at the San Francisco International Movie Festival and it was amazing. It had a running time of approx. 90 minutes just I'm not actually sure because I couldn't accept my eyes off of the screen. The moving picture unfolds chronologically and covers the formative years of Jim Jones' life and the birth, rise and eventual demise of the People's Temple. The story is told through interviews with the surviving members of the People's Temple, their family members and the survivors of Congressman Leo Ryan'south ill-fated trip to Guyana. The director of the picture show forces us to expect at the People'south Temple on it'southward own merits and set aside the preconceived notions we have regarding the "mass suicide" and the tired notion that the members of the church building were cult members who enthusiastically drank cyanide laced kool-aid to ascend to heaven. The onetime members of the church building come off as enlightened idealists who were searching for a life with meaning in a society that ignored them because of their poverty or the colour of their skin and they found their champion in Jim Jones. This film doesn't ask questions and respond them; it provides y'all w/ data and you are forced to disseminate information technology yourself. Nosotros get to see Jones for what he was: a father, a political power broker, sometime time preacher, son of a dysfunctional family, molester, savior, integrationist and killer.The camera doesn't pass judgment on history it just records information technology. This documentary fills in the gaps of a story that we idea knew. The music, archival photos and motion-picture show footage used are amazing. I would highly recommend this film to anyone who is interested in the subject. The documentary unfolds like a dream and takes you on ride through the history of the People's Temple, it grabs you lot and doesn't permit go.
32 out of 34 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An American Tragedy
This story is so much more complex than news reports of the Republic of guyana tragedy would have us believe. The members of The People's Temple had such altruistic intentions: they had a vision of a Utopian order where racial harmony and true brotherhood was the order of the day. They wanted to guarantee intendance for the poor, the elderly, children....and they wanted to create real customs. This doco manages to tell the whole story, while honoring the pure intentions of the Temple members, and even shedding light on the paradoxical cult leader, Jim Jones - a man who was impressively liberal and progressive, politically, but frighteningly meglomaniacal and abusive, when it came to leading his "flock." The strength of this moving-picture show lies in the fact that it isn't just a play-by-play from afar, but a collection of first-paw interviews with people who were actually there, and who knew the central players. A must-see for anyone who was alive and aware went these events took place.
19 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A practiced history of Jim Jones's Peoples Temple
I saw this in San Francisco, where the Peoples Temple was located in the 70s. Onetime Peoples Temple members and the director and writer of the movie were nowadays (and there was discussion after the screening). It was certainly a powerful place and way to see information technology, merely I think the movie stands on its own. It does a good job of showing what attracted people to the Peoples Temple and how, gradually, things started to go very wrong. There is footage from the days of the Peoples Temple also as new and moving testimony (that feels like the right word) from former members and family of members.
It's not clear if it volition get distributed theatrically only, if not, the director said it will air on PBS in 2007. Highly recommended.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Jonestown
This is a very accomplished documentary. Information technology reveals, via its interviewees, a level of despair and dismay that the by 20 eight years have withal to efface. Whole families - indeed an unabridged community were liquidated in minutes on November 18, 1978. Jim Jones was a conventional mid-western preacher in every respect bar one - his empathy for African Americans, and therefore his delivery to the idea of a racially integrated church building. Of course many conventional churches - Catholics, Episcopalians, Lutherans, Presbyterians, etc., reached out to marginalised communities, just this trend was peradventure less pronounced in the southern evangelical tradition, which was highly influential in Jones' home land of Indiana (which had been the epicentre of Klu Klux Klan activeness in the decade earlier Jones' birth under the leadership of Ed Jackson and the infamous David Stephenson). The fact that Jones was a little alee of the curve on the most sensitive and essential issue in American society, and since he was cursed by an unusual sense of cocky-conventionalities, it led him to believe that he was special, and that his message and the principles past which he operated his church building, were unique. In one case he comprehended the uniqueness of his mission at that place was really no limit to his ambitions - he could exist anything - he could be the son of God or he could exist an avenging affections. In fact he was besides a huckster and con-human of the first order with a vastly inflated sense of his own importance, and his relative ignorance of ecclesiastical history prevented him from acknowledging that there accept been several important communistic sects in the Christian tradition - not least in America (viz. the early on Anabaptists in Reformation Germany, the Diggers/Truthful Levellers in Commonwealth England, the Shakers and certain aspects of Mormonism, etc.).
As Jones staked out ever greater claims for himself, he placed himself on a trajectory of spiritual fraud that was so steep that whatever mis-step or retreat might bring his whole house of cards to the point of plummet. He therefore became hopelessly compromised: he could either become the messiah or another 1 of California's many prison inmates. The stress of this might explicate the paranoia, the abuse of those in his power and the self-abuse that occurred as his 'ministry' progressed. In the end he had taken his loyal and long-suffering congregation so far (both emotionally and physically) that he must take reasoned that the only way of evading an wretched reckoning was past some form of abdication - which took the form of his ain suicide and the murder of almost all of his followers. Jones was all of a piece with the likes of Charles Manson or David Koresh.
In view of his increasingly outré behaviour, it was about inevitable that he should have gravitated towards San Francisco and that he should have go prominent in local politics under the aegis of the well-meaning (but arguably misguided) George Moscone. The movie does non mention the close connections between the doomed Leo Ryan and Moscone, nor the imminent bump-off of Moscone and Harvey Milk by Dan White. That was unfortunate, because it underscored the strangeness of this remarkable story. All the same, it is by no means a fatal omission. I would accept appreciated some item on the mental attitude of the Guyanese government to this foreign Temple in the jungle. Did the government of Forbes Burnham and Arthur Chung know anything nearly information technology and the danger that cult members were in? Did they make whatsoever attempt to intervene?
I saw this motion picture equally part of the 2006 Times/BFI London Picture show Festival, and information technology is regrettable that information technology did not receive more publicity (non to the lowest degree in The Times itself). The story was told dead direct with little of the ostentatious editing that is now so common in documentaries, and is all the more constructive for information technology. The audience left the theatre in something approaching a state of utter pathos - a tribute to the terrible nature of the story, the integrity of the witnesses and the ability of Stanley Nelson and his colleagues.
The film contains many scenes (footage of services in People'south Temple) that seem joyous - and they are all the more tragic for that. Nevertheless I could never quite tell what was in the eyes of all these doomed worshippers (many of whom were otherwise helpless, lonely and delicate). Was it rapture or was it...terror?
7 out of eight found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The all-time Peoples Temple documentary so far, merely...
Alarm: Spoilers
The best Peoples Temple documentary then far, but there remains considerable room for improvement. "The Life and Death of Peoples Temple" glosses over numerous baroque events in the life of Jim Jones, such every bit his acquaintance with Dan Mitrione--an infamous undercover CIA operative who was assassinated in Uruguay in 1970--and Jones's extended stay in Brazil during the early 1960s. (Mitrione was there at the same time, working for the U.S. State Section, and the CIA has admitted that information technology opened a file on Jones when Mitrione was dispatched to Brazil in September 1960). These are established facts, not unverified rumors, so it seems but lazy to exclude them from what purports to be an evenhanded account of Jones'due south quasi-religious Marxist cult. Also unexamined here is the medical evidence indicating that most of the 913 victims at Jonestown did not commit suicide, but were murdered. Survivor Stanley Clayton, who is interviewed in the motion picture, saw adults being forcibly injected with cyanide before he escaped from the isolated jungle settlement (run into Tim Reiterman'southward "Raven: The Untold Story of the Rev. Jim Jones and His People"), which appears to confirm the findings of Republic of guyana'due south chief pathologist Dr. Leslie Mootoo, who was the first to examine the bodies. Those findings, all the same, are not discussed in the documentary. Were mind control experiments being conducted at Jonestown? (There were big amounts of drugs like sodium thiopental and chloral hydrate in the compound'south medical facilities.) Was Jim Jones connected to the CIA, and did the agency seize the perfect opportunity to silence Congressman Leo Ryan, i of its nigh vocal critics? "The Life and Death of Peoples Temple" eschews these questions, predictably reducing the story--once more--to a real-life soap opera about a megalomaniac and his tragically misguided disciples. The interviews with those who knew Jones and worked alongside or followed him are fascinating, but significant and mayhap crucial chunks of the Peoples Temple saga are missing from this movie.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Mystery Continues
This pic documents the life of Jim Jones, his emergence as a charismatic and successful religious figure, and his eventual downfall.
The whole People's Temple story always struck me as but another of the 60'southward cult phenomena. We had Rajneesh and his farm, and uncountable other guru's who exploited, and continue to exploit, large numbers of gullible followers. The Moonies are still with u.s.a., but well below the radar most of the fourth dimension.
What's odd almost Jim Jones -- to me, anyway -- is that no one really seems to know who this guy really was. This motion picture gives more insight than annihilation else I've seen or read. Information technology talks about his babyhood, which was extremely poor, and his family situation, which was as grim, and then we get some insight at that place. Just he was a very carefully guarded swain. Always wearing those shades, always talking in the way of a preacher. Merely who was he actually? What was he like when he took off the robes and had a beer? We may never know. His followers certainly didn't know, and no doubtfulness that'south a major role of the problem. There is i scene in this documentary in which Jones is standing at the back of a group of people at a large gathering, and his demeanor reminded me of the dictator in Due north Korea -- information technology was that kind of vague, arrogant, totally in command expect. Chilling.
The nigh telling annotate in this film was the remark made by one of the PT's former members, who said "No one always goes and joins a cult. They bring together a church, or a club." Just what is the tipping betoken at which people tin tolerate psychological and physical abuse against themselves and their friends? We don't get an reply to that. The people who made this film didn't have to tell the states the answer, but information technology would have been a better film if they had.
ten out of fourteen found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
illuminating, just leaves and so many questions ...
I saw this at the London Moving picture Festival, and was impressed past what appeared to be a balanced picture - of both the Peoples Temple church and Jim Jones himself. The motion picture is captivating in its chronological story telling, leading up to the tragic events in Guyana.
However I did find the echo use of some archival footage a bit weak, and unless I missed it, it was never explained that the "Planning Commission" was function of the Peoples Temple itself.
Like any skilful documentary, it left me wanting to find out more, only I did think that it was an omission not to endeavor any consideration of what led Jones to turn what had been a beneficial organisation, into a murderous 1. Neither does the film attempt to look into how the organisation was run - presumably Jones couldn't accept directly controlled the 1,000 inhabitants of Jonestown? The source of the poison and weapons is likewise a subject field that doesn't feature, or the question of what happened to the money afterwards?
Overall this is a really interesting movie, particularly for those of us who were besides young to call up the events.
13 out of nineteen found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
You Must Meet This!
I just ordered the DVD edition of this extraordinary documentary about Jonestown and the People's Temple. Information technology'south probably one of the most under-written events of our times. We don't know plenty to pass judgment or should we on the members of the People'due south Temple. They all had their reasons for joining and when they got in. Information technology was very difficult to get out. Jim Jones Sr. was a very powerful man both in politics and in the church. He persuaded people to sign over their life savings, their children, their homes, and their lives to him. He sought power, domination, and ultimate control over his members who he feigned to dearest. He was maniac, madman, religious leader who sent hundreds to their deaths because his reign of terror was finally over after the Congressman's visit. He believed information technology was all over and in fact he was dying and so was Marcy, his long-suffering married woman, who endured humiliation and his infidelities. In the stop, Jim Jones was the ultimate coward, afraid of death, so he brought hundreds into his programme. The revolutionary suicide was practiced many times before during the white nights of horror. This time, it was real. It didn't have to exist. Our government and the Guyanese should have been more involved. There was a warrant out for his abort and the custody battle over John Victor Stoen should accept been over and he should accept been returned to his parents in America who were former members. Information technology should have never happened but it did and we must larn from information technology or 900 died in vain.
1 out of one found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Very Informative, Hearthbreaking Companion Piece to Guyana Tragedy
Warning: Spoilers
The documentary "The Life and Death of the Peoples Temple" dives into the 1978 murder/suicide of over 900 members of Jim Jones' Peoples Temple due to poisoned punch and is told from the POV of one-time cult members. These members, all men and women, blackness and white tell their stories of cult life in an honest, non-flinching way. Jim Jones opened his cult to every walk of human society; young, old, white, black, male and female.
These old members tell stories well-nigh Jim Jones' drug abuse, God complex, and sexual molestation against them and others. Some similar Hue Folsom use a defense machinery of laughing near Jones' perversions and others like Tim Carver are more solemn when talking most such things. People are dissimilar and everyone reacts to trauma in his or her own manner.
To hear these traumatized ex-members talk about the aftermath of the poisoning is quite sorry and chilling. You can see the pain in the optics of Grace Stoen, Tim Carver, and Vern Gosney when they talk about the loss of their young sons in Jonestown!
I exercise hope doing this documentary was therapeutic for all involved and they receive love and support from the viewers of this documentary and from others.
2 out of 2 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very decent documentary, but not genius
This is i of these stories that tin can exist revisited over and over once again while trying to sympathize what actually happened. What are the reasons that brand people do horrible things without actually wanting or understanding why do they practice them. It is a film about commonage delusion and manipulation... or maybe information technology is a film near fright and dubiousness towards life?
Well, I wish I could respond these questions after this documentary. But I tin't, because despite it'due south very acceptable technical quality, the option of a chronological narration doesn't practice much to add depth to a grapheme larger than life as Jim Jones was.
The film did a lot to enlighten me in the origins of the church, it's racial integration and as well its claims against social inequality. Just the character itself remains a mystery to me. His motivations, the techniques he used to command his followers. It is all depicted very lightly and without much intellectual depth. There are moments when some of the cult followers say things about Jones that could exist further explored, simply unfortunately the managing director chooses to leave them as nearly an anecdote.
And this is what I retrieve it is the biggest concern I have confronting this very interesting film. The narration makes Jones announced as an eccentric egomaniac. Simply the truth is that one hints there was so much more in his plans. It is just not plausible that he only made up the mass suicide- murder idea on the become. In that location is something utterly well idea out about how everything happened. This is pure evil at work, non very different to the Jew extermination by the Nazis. There was a programme, and I am certain that in this case there was a very well laid out plan. Just the film makes it all announced almost as random as the weather.
It is a pity, because the archive footage is varied and fantabulous. But I tin't assistance but wonder what Errol Morris would have done of this flick. Probably a masterpiece, because he would have fabricated what he does best: Portray characters with total precision.
Still, an interesting documentary to lookout.
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An insightful look into an horrific event
The Jonestown Massacre is an result so horrible and unique that it's hard to fathom that it did in fact happen; such is the unbelievable nature of its waste product of human life. In this made for boob tube documentary commissioned past PBS, nosotros become an insight into the events leading upwardly to and also during the mass suicide that killed over 900 followers of demented church leader Jim Jones.
Director Stanley Nelson has done a fine job gathering together a range of talking heads who experienced the workings of Jones outset hand and his also unearthed some quite startling archival footage and phonation recordings to give usa an eerily insightful look at what took place in the People's Temple and what exactly Jones preached on the twenty-four hours the Cool Aid supplies were used for the virtually sinister reasons possible. These uses of real life footage and voice recordings create the documentary's most powerful moments and a culmination of extreme evil at the end becomes jaw droopingly hard to sit down through every bit men, women and children (some babies) were told they needed to end their life all for the sake of the greater expert. While these elements combine to create a morbidly fascinating look into the People's Temple the film lacks an overall sense of achievement in its telling of Jones and his motivations.
Yous get the feeling that the quintessential wait into this grouping and its manipulative leader is notwithstanding to be told, as here Nelson fail'southward to properly pinpoint just what drew Jones to not only start the grouping, but finish the grouping and the film remains frustratingly afar in many avenues when it comes to the focus of who Jones was and what he wanted. The world may never truly understand simply what collection this evil human being and what also drew then many to feel like they were powerless to stop the man or simply say no to him but surely there is more insight to be constitute for the background of such an evil human being.
While not entertainment in whatsoever stretch of the imagination, Jonestown: The Life and Expiry of People'south Temple is an intriguing expect into an issue that occurred not that long ago and remains to this 24-hour interval ane of the about horrific acts of violence always seen and an example of bullheaded faith leading to destruction.
3 loudspeaker announcements out of v
For more than motion picture reviews and opinions check into -
www.jordanandeddie.wordpress.com
1 out of 1 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Utopia From Hell
Those poor people that died; with great sincerity, they trusted the good reverend Jim Jones. He was their "father", their leader; he could practice no wrong. Jones promised a better life for his followers in the jungles of Guyana. Jonestown was to be a utopia on earth. And all those who went ... believed. All the same, in reality, Jones was a flimflam homo, a con artist, a monster suffering from paranoia, egomania, and delusions of grandeur.
This documentary retells the infamous story, with archival footage of Jones' past, and how he organized the Peoples Temple in California. We learn that Jones, charismatic and charming, was quite deceptive, and that he sold himself equally God to his flock: "Some people see a peachy deal of God in my body; they see Christ in me."
Though Jonestown residents seemed superficially happy, trouble lurked underneath the smiles and laughter. Upon the visit of a U.S. Congressman and photographic camera crew, a number of Jonestown residents wanted to leave. Which didn't sit well with the good reverend, infinitely suspicious of the intentions both of his own people and of the U.S. Regime.
The start 48-infinitesimal segment of this documentary describes general events before the motion to Guyana, and consists largely of interviews. Merely in the second half does the film actually item the last couple of days, November 17th and 18th, 1978. Only with filmed events at the scene, and photos, that last 25-minute segment is riveting in its horrifying reality.
The documentary could have been ameliorate. Peculiarly in the first one-half, there are style besides many repetitive interviews, which focus on impressions rather than facts. I would like to have seen a more factual presentation. Too much time is spent on pre-Guyana events. And the photos don't identify who is in the pictures.
Withal, the real-life story itself is and so overwhelming, and so powerful, that even a mediocre product tin can exist riveting and astonishing, as this one is. That such an idealized utopia could morph so quickly into a hellish nightmare shows what a poisonous mix isolation, gullibility, and mass hypnosis can exist.
1 out of 1 institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Historical refresher grade
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this recently at the 2007 Palm Springs International Movie Festival. It had a WHG Boston logo at the beginning credit scroll so I would assume that this volition aired on PBS tv set stations. Listening to comments from viewers leaving the theater I was surprised that many had never heard of Jim Jones and Jonestown or could barely remember it. Every bit for me, this documentary fell brusk in that information technology never really told me anything about Jones and his doomed cult that I didn't already know. This is the story of the charismatic religious leader Jim Jones and his beginnings in Indiana to his moving to California and ultimately founding the Peoples Temple based in San Francisco where he congenital a large congregation of predominantly black parishioners and their families and former white hippies. He gained political clout merely when an investigation into how is organization is run is launched he moves the temple to a remote South American jungle. It compiles news footage, grainy home movies from temple members and still photographs along with some interviews of people who lost family members and survivors. It's being submitted equally a Best Documentary out of the USA to the Academy Awards merely this is more of a boob tube movie than a theatrical release. It leaves many unanswered questions every bit to where they got their weapons and cyanide? Who used the weapons to control the 900 into forcible suicide? What happened to those who oversaw the mass suicide? did they live and escape into the jungle? How did his bureaucracy piece of work? What happened to all the coin that was being used to run Jonestown? This is a good documentary from director Stanley Nelson and writer Marcia Smith who have teamed together on several goggle box documentaries. It'due south not great just information technology'due south worth a look. I would give this a 7.0 out of ten.
2 out of three found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Horrific story
The horrific story of the Jonestown massacre never stops to stir powerful emotions in all of u.s.. A man who attempted to fight segregation and racism in 1950's Indiana ends up equally a crazy communist manner dictator and slaughters over 900 hundred of his flock. Information technology is piece of cake to run into how Jim Jones managed to attract so many faithful in the starting time. There are lost souls everywhere, and it seems there are more than of them every day. He reached to those who didn't matter in a society obsessed with coin and success. He provided family unit to many who never had it. And most of all he fabricated those who believed in him important and unique.But, alas that kind of power and admiration always ends in tragedy. Jim Jones was a drug aficionado and a false, and in a higher place all a dangerous, disturbed person. The event is hundreds of dead and many more than damaged for life. There is one question that poses itself. Why is information technology that in our country, "the greatest land on earth", so many people seek solace in the next world following crazed prophets. The answer to that question might be a sobering one. There is no room for failure and weakness in America. When that happens, you are on your own. Until some Jones, Koresh or Alamo comes along and the real horror starts.
1 out of i found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Fascinating Documentary of One of Modern History's Darkest and Most Agonizing Capacity
The events that led to the deaths of 909 Americans, nigh of whom voluntarily gave up their lives under the scout and orders of a sadistic, egomaniacal, hypocritical, merely disarming madman are, by themselves, very difficult to accept. Any reasonable person would non want to have that these things take happened, and proceed to happen today on a lower magnitude. However, information technology is best to know how these things happen so that history doesn't repeat itself. It is a lesson that, ironically, was actually spelled out in all capital letters on a sign that hung prominently in Jonestown, Guyana: "THOSE WHO CANNOT REMEMBER THE Past ARE DOOMED TO Repeat IT". It'south even more ironic that this particular sign can be seen in the haunting photographs hanging over the lifeless bodies of unfortunate victims.
The things that happened in Guyana on November 18, 1978 are a tough pill to swallow, that's for certain. What'due south corking virtually a documentary similar "Jonestown: The Life And Decease of People'south Temple" is that many of the events leading up to the notorious mass suicides are unfolded with the aid of vast amounts of archive footage, revealing photographs, and absolutely no narration whatsoever. The accounts of more a dozen former People'due south Temple members, including some who miraculously made information technology out of Jonestown alive, provide the much-needed support for this heavy-handed historical business relationship.
Viewers who are unaware of the events, or who don't know where the expression "drinking the purple Kool Aid" comes from, will probably be shocked even in the get-go five minutes of this movie. It is then that the who, what, when, where and how are revealed, none of which is pretty. It is to notice out the why that many people, including myself, would want to watch this documentary.
Deborah Layton, a former People'south Temple member who wrote a bestselling book near her ordeal with Reverend Jim Jones and his followers, starts the documentary out correct past saying, "Nobody joins a cult. Nobody joins something they recall's gonna hurt them. Y'all join a religious arrangement, you join a political movement, and you join with people that you actually like". Upon hearing this statement, I could not help but recollect of the saying, "The road to Hell is paved with good intentions".
More than pertinent to this story, it seemed as though Jim Jones founded the People'due south Temple on very good intentions. His church embraced integration when many other churches were against information technology. When his congregation grew, the Temple provided a swell corporeality of customs service. Every bit you lot picket the footage of the church services, you lot run into so many happy people, and it's piece of cake to forget the magnitude of the group's eventual demise.
In fact, the interviewees do a great chore expressing their reasons for joining the Temple. They also delve into some interesting details about when Jim Jones revealed his true intentions to them behind closed doors. Allow'south just say that some of his tactics ranged from public humiliation to sodomy.
Of course, once Reverend Jones and company hightail information technology to a remote location in Guyana, the story gets even more disturbing. The opinions of Jonestown vary amongst the survivors. Some hated it from the offset, while others loved information technology up until the very end. Regardless, the accounts that came from all these people, including Jim Jones' adopted African-American son Jim Jones, Jr., are all fascinating.
Managing director Stanley Nelson did some neat research for this documentary, and the interviews served every bit the backbone for this project. The only weakness the documentary has involves the aftermath of the survivors. You're given an epilogue consisting solely of what family unit and friends each surviving member lost. What I wanted to know, even so, is how the survivors, who had given their lives and possessions to the People'south Temple, moved on from the ordeal. They lost everything, yet when it was probably easiest to kill themselves along with the other Guyana members, they are notwithstanding around today to tell the tale. It likewise would have been nice to know if they are successful or not.
Really, Nelson wanted to include such data, just claimed he ran out of fourth dimension. If he directs a companion piece to this documentary that includes such data, it would exist information that would showtime the pain of such a tragedy at least a lilliputian, and that is all near viewers could ask for in this instance.
1 out of i found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Murder By Manipulation
Offset word tells. Never trust anything starting with 'Peoples...'
Unfortunately, Jim Jones' cult (Peoples Temple) was targeting detail groups who were over-neat to believe in Utopia, many of them apprehensive Afro-Americans, who seem to outnumber the other races in a manner that makes this rainbow coalition await a bit doubtable from the start. The black dimension is, even so, the central business of manager Stanley Nelson, and that is how this 85-minute documentary differs from many others on the same horribly fascinating subject. It also means that you are better to have watched some of these first, as the present piece of work naturally gives y'all a skewed version of the story.
Only the kickoff and final sections are directly sequential - Jones' boyhood, so the climactic 24 hours leading upwardly to the murder/suicide of 900 trusting believers. The primary body of the motion picture is taken up with first-hand testimonies past those connected with the Temple, either as bereaved relatives or disillusioned whistleblowers. Not one in ten of these could be described every bit people of critical insight. In fact, 'uncritical' is probably the key word. Long before they swallowed their lethal poison, they were swallowing a cheap mix of cult-theory, hot-gospeller gabble and theatrical stunts, including a transparently fake miracle with a wheelchair-spring 'patient' who is inspired to get up and walk.
Some of their comments are so stupid that they tin just be good news for any budding cult-leader, perhaps feeling tempted after watching an exceptionally glamorous whistleblower confessing that she surrendered her virtue to Jones when he said "I'm doing this for you, Debbie." One survivor, clearly unteachable, defends Jones on the grounds that "At least we tried to brand a change". (Well, that really does leave the residual of us feeling narrow-minded.) Other reactions include "It all looked so plausible", "Information technology looked like freedom" and "Nosotros had fun".
At the risk of talking cliché, it is impossible non to annotation the Hitler parallels, especially the hypnotic effect on crowds and the appeals to turn-in your own family for signs of disloyalty. And his own suicide, at least, was on the cards. For he had shown that he was a homo liable to cutting-and-run. When the first whistleblower went to the press, Jones was on a plane to Guyana before the morning papers had even hit the street. And once that brave and unusually dutiful congressman Leo Ryan came to investigate on behalf of his worried constituents, information technology was clear that everything was almost to unravel, and that Jones and his ghastly cult might as well self-destruct once and for all.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Human, the Myth, the Maniac
November 18th, 1978 was a tragic day in Jonestown, Guyana. If the 909 who died on that day had all died by their own hands, and so it would exist considered the largest deed of mass suicide ever; but they didn't all die past their ain hands, many were shot and many others were forced to "drink the Kool-Aid" at gun point. The orchestrator, Jim Jones, didn't fifty-fifty have the cojones to drink himself. He ordered someone to shoot him in the head.
"Jonestown: The Life & Death of Peoples Temple" is a documentary that covers Jim Jones and his followers and how they arrived at that fateful day. The fact is Jim Jones didn't aggregate the corporeality of followers he had by blow, nor was information technology a malicious plot. Jim Jones was a charismatic, eloquent preacher from Indiana who was preaching and practicing integration and other socially progressive ideals when information technology was unpopular. The message he had was very appealing, especially to Black folks. Over fourth dimension his bulletin and his behavior changed to get more than paranoid, decision-making, and maniacal.
"Jonestown" interviews a dozen or so ex-members, family unit of members, journalists, and others who had contact with Jim Jones and/or Jonestown. Nosotros hear how information technology is people brutal in love with Jim Jones and the Peoples Temple and what made them become suspicious and disenchanted with Jim Jones and the Peoples Temple. Information technology's a fascinating saga simply because information technology involved and so many people.
It'south easy to condemn cult members and make them as being unproblematic-minded sycophants, merely I would proffer that all of u.s. want to have a sense of belonging. Jim Jones offered a existent customs and family unit to and then many that it wasn't crazy to join the Peoples Temple, for them it was crazy not to. It's unfortunate that the Peoples Temple experiment in brotherly love and working for the mutual good was completely tied to ane human and his ever-deteriorating listen land. The lives lost on November 18, 1978 wasn't the only matter lost that day.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An awful and confused documentary about a tragic only stimulating story.
Warning: Spoilers
This could have been a great exercise in understanding the human being status and the nature of religious cults but instead we get a one-half-hearted, breezy petty movie with clumsy editing and shallow, childish themes. It completely fails to intelligently appraise what happened.
The romanticized ending where the ex-members go on in tears about how they tried to create paradise on earth and that even though it failed, at least they made the effort was only too much. Free from the cult, these people go along to be idiotic, pathetically vulnerable homo beings without a shred of nobility or intelligence - completely content with playing "victim". Sure were brainwashed and driveling but information technology's been years since the incident and these grown men and women are withal unable to assume partial responsibleness for the mass killings of innocent kids and random politicians. Jim Jones is merely one man. Ultimately it's the blind followers and sad, silly, co-dependent escapists easily lured by unrealistic promises who enable psychopaths similar Jim Jones to thrive. This moving-picture show deserves to be burned for catastrophe on such a ridiculous, offensive note.
five out of viii institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Paints a clearer picture of what happened that day in 1978
The greatest documentaries will keep you fascinated throughout, regardless of whether you lot know the upshot or not. The focus of Jonestown: The Life and Decease of Peoples Temple is the mysterious and agonizing mass-suicide of 909 people in the jungles of Republic of guyana, in a new settlement they dubbed 'Jonestown' later on their fanatical leader Jim Jones. This was a well publicised outcome, but has only really been tagged every bit a simple 'cult ritual', with all the finer details frustratingly spared. Jonestown delves deeper into this all the same-shocking event, and exposes non a pocket-size ground forces of brainwashed fanatics, but a customs terrified past a maniacal command-freak with a God complex.
Jim Jones was a solitary child in a household dominated past an unloving, alcoholic father. He sought refuge in the church building where he plant a family he belonged to, and eventually became a preacher. While preaching for civil rights and racial equality, he began to aggregate a large post-obit, and shortly his small community was also large for Indiana, and they all relocated to California where they became known equally the Peoples Temple. Followers had there medical bills, travel expenses, clothes and near everything else paid for them, as to be a member you lot were expected to work and earn your place. Presently though, members began defecting, and Jones and Peoples Temple fled to Guyana later a magazine commodity was due to be published, exposing sexual corruption, physical humiliation and staged healings at the hands of Jones.
Sadly, this documentary leaves many questions unanswered, namely surrounding Jones himself, who remains a - strangely uncharismatic - mystery. Even so through interviews with survivors and Jones's adopted son, we larn that political power gained through the growth of Peoples Temple and his abuse of drugs and alcohol, presently led to his psychological demise. His preachings of racial equality helped him earn the backing of elderly black women, and soon plenty liberal white youngsters, and his one-time-world gospel style chop-chop earned him the admiration of these social outcasts. Merely nosotros hear him preach about how there is no sky above, and if these people want him to be their God, then he volition play that role. This would be blasphemy in nigh people's eyes, still these people on the crust of order were merely looking for some kind of stability and sense of belonging.
Of the actual massacre itself, in that location is a surprisingly big amount of video and audio recordings. The camp has an atmosphere of hushful fear, that everyone is thinking the same thing but no-one dare say it. Jones'southward voice blasted out his gibberish, alcohol-fuelled rants most not-stop while the followers did their jobs. The murder of Congressman Leo Ryan sets in movement a terrifying sequence of events, all defenseless mainly on sound, equally Jones tells his members that it's time to die. His vox urging the children to "bustle, hurry," is particularly chilling. Information technology'south even so difficult to believe how this happened. A man who could have had all the ability he craved, both politically and financially, merely seemed to be driven more past the demand to command and dominate his loyal followers. Similar I said before, Jim Jones nevertheless remains a mystery, but the movie does shed some light on the human, and paints a clearer picture show of what happened that twenty-four hours on November 18th, 1978.
www.the-wrath-of-blog.blogspot.com
0 out of 0 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Also Much Power
Proficient doco. I'll never understand how big groups of sheeple put so much energy towards ane man. It's happened time and time over again. Information technology's an interesting study to run into how much praise a human can take before he/she begins believing the BS that everyone'southward feeding him. If people kissed my barrel constantly and told me I'chiliad their father/God I'd end up doing crazy stuff as well. Most of these crazy leaders enjoy leaving clues around that hint at exactly what their programme is, and followers turn a blind center to it. The sign in the camp says information technology all "Those who cannot call back the past are condemned to repeat it."
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Unfortunately doesn't tell the whole story
Warning: Spoilers
This documentary is indispensible because of the rare footage Stanley Nelson was able to discover. However, the narrative of this pic leaves out quite a fleck about Jim Jones and his People's Temple. Afterwards viewing the Jim Jones biography on A&E and reading Deborah Layton'due south excellent book "Seductive Poison" I get the impression Nelson is only telling i office of a larger more than complicated story with his 90 minute documentary.
(Possible spoilers ahead) The primary trouble is Nelson doesn't portay well enough how most of the members of People's Temple were basically fooled by Jim Jones into thinking he was running a church or religious move. Jones claimed to be a pastor. However, he was deep down a socialist who didn't really believe in God. And no 1 could say he behaved like a pastor (multiple sexual partners, drinking/drugging)
He basically ran the People's Temple like a communist government. All of the tactics he employed were influenced by Marx, Lenin and various communist countries. Then while people thought they were joining a church they were in fact joining a political arrangement that wanted America to prefer socialism to solve all its social ills.
While mamy well intentioned members may not accept known what they were a office of before Guyana. I retrieve they saw clearly one time they moved to Jonestown that they were in fact involved in a movement that had nothing to do with Jesus Christ. With Jonestown, Jim Jones had created his ain little Soviet Union or Cuba. In fact he secretly planned to movement his flock to Russia.
Every bit Deborah Layton explains in her book, the temple had to claim to be a church so they could get tax breaks and avoid beingness audited. But they were in fact a socialist organisation. Nelson makes a big deal on the DVD of showing how "happy" the members of Jonestown looked on that last nighttime before their suicides. And how information technology was still a vibrant community. The truth is establish in Layton's book which I doubt the motion-picture show makers bothered to read.
She explains that when outsiders visited, Jones instructed his followers to look happy and say they had no desire to exit. And how in fact many residents appeared happy because they were getting a day off work and real food. Also, Layton explains that many members of Jonestown couldn't go out considering they'd donated their life savings, SS checks and sold their homes to support the temple. So if they returned to u.s. they would take to start over with no money. So of course they didn't want to leave. Jones had all their money.
I wish the documentary would have clearly shown what really went down with the People's Temple. How Jones took advantage of poor minorities and rebellious immature people and manipulated them for his own personal goals. I don't even recollect Jones prepare out to form a cult. However, he did desire power, wealth and control. And a harem of adoring, young attractive women around him that he could make to anything.
In the end, Nelson should have done a better job of explaining the external factors that made members want to stay in the People's Temple no matter what. The definitive volume on Jonestown has been written (Seductive Poison). However, the definitive documentary has yet to exist made. Don't be fooled by the narrow view of the Jonestown tragedy that is presented in this film. Read Layton'due south volume are watch the A&Eastward documentaries. They assist tell the full story about what really went on in Jonestown. Yet, the "why" is what Nelson fails to reply.
three out of nine found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Riveting documentary on a mysterious cult with a gruesome ending
Wow. This documentary actually made a huge impression on me. I'm more than of an animal guy myself, simply I have to say, a couple of scenes in this documentary actually got to me. I caught this on television without knowing what information technology was about beforehand, and not having heard of Jonestown at all. And like I said, some scenes towards the end are truly horrifying. One shot in particular took me by surprise, and really stabbed me in the feels(..as the kids say these days). Totally heartbreaking.
The whole story is fascinating as hell, and Jim Jones is actually charismatic, and yous tin kind of understand how/why people, for some reason or other, was mesmerized by him.
This whole cult-thing is a fascinating and scary concept, and it'due south interesting to meet how stuff like this can really happen. With commentary from actual people who were actually there.
I tin can also recommend "The Sacrament" which is a mystery/thriller/horror based on these events.
0 out of ane institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Source: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0762111/reviews
0 Response to "Jonestown the Life and Death of Peoples Temple Reviews"
إرسال تعليق